Menu
Cart

No Respect for Property Rights!

Posted by 2 on

As the artist and creator of my own designs, I am particularly disturbed when I hear about large companies ripping off the designs of individual artists. The recent controversy surrounding Urban Outfitters and the work of Indie artist, Stevie Koerner, is an excellent example. Stevie created some unusual and attractive jewelry with the following theme, “I ‘heart’ the US” or “I ‘heart’ Canada”. Urban Outfitters reproduced her designs without her permission and didn’t even compensate her for her creativity. The jewelry designs are just too close to be an accident. When Urban Outfitters was challenged about this issue, they claimed the situation was coincidental. When researching for this blog post, I came across several other examples in which Urban Outfitters stole the creations of an artist, for example, the Johnny Cupcakes shirt. The artist provided a few shirt samples for review to the Urban Outfitters buyers. Next thing you know, his designs appeared in their stores but Johnny Cupcake didn’t receive any compensation for his work. This happens all too often. I was on the Internet about a year ago and I stumbled upon the Shanghai Textile Company web site, which had posted images of my products (they even used my photographs) followed by the claim they are the designer and manufacturer of Tail Wags Helmet Covers. This is nonsense! I have never used a Chinese manufacturer and I am the SOLE designer of Tail Wags designs. All of my designs have been copyrighted and trademarked as fully as possible. The problem is some overseas companies do not recognize or respect intellectual property rights. Even large chains like Gucci and Prada can’t seem to successfully stop imitation goods of their designs from being manufactured illegally in China. So how is a small company like Tail Wags Helmet Covers supposed to fight them? The same is true for individual artists such as Stevie Koerner. In the United States and Canada, individuals and small companies have a better chance of fighting for their property rights because our courts respect copyright and trademark laws. But legal proceedings are expensive and not everyone has the money to fight the big companies. That’s why companies like Urban Outfitters have been getting away with this practice for years. However, social media is beginning to change the landscape in favour of individuals. Stevie Koerner has received tremendous support from the public via the social media network. There is a growing groundswell of people encouraging others to boycott Urban Outfitters. I will never purchase any products from Urban Outfitters and I would encourage you to do the same. Think of the problem in these terms: If you were an artist and you made your living by selling your art work, how would you feel if a large corporation took your ideas, mass produced them and then made a huge profit from your work – without compensating you a cent? Please think twice before buying a product knock-off! It’s the little guys that are being hurt.

Share this post



← Older Post Newer Post →


6 comments

  • That is terrible. I read that article the other day. It’s hard to earn an honest living when people rip off other people’s ideas. So sad.

    Kimberly on
  • I am so sorry to hear what’s happening Katie! I can’t begin to understand why people would be so unscrupulous – it’s no different than robbing a bank. I hope you find a way to receive retribution. My heart truly goes out to you!

    Karyn Climans on
  • I am amidst a copyright battle myself, I run a successful jewellery business and my original work has been copied by none other than my partners ex girlfriend who has developed an obsession with my business, she has gone from hotel receptionist to posting claiming now to be a jewellery designer and copying identically my work. She has no response other than denial to my lawyers letter and claims the reason for the identical work is we must buy our supplies from the same places…So do half of the jewellery industry and anyone else is yet to create identical work! Frustrating does not even come close…Urban Outfitters are a disgrace. I worked as an accessories buyer for years for a retailer whos clothing buyers bought t’s from a store to send to their suppliers to copy!!

    Katie on
  • Pam: the crazy thing is that if someone tried to rip off an Urban Outfitters idea or logo etc, they would be the first to take legal action. They forget that it’s a two way street!

    Karyn Climans on
  • Well said, Karyn. Knock-offs hurt. It blows my mind that main-stream companies engage in those sorts of unethical business practices. Disgusting.

    Pam @writewrds on

Leave a comment